My So Called Digital GeoWorld
Posted by Aaron VanWieren on 07 Aug 2007 at 03:15 am | Tagged as: Cartography And GIS
It is obvious we live in a digital information age, data is transformed into information and is presented immediately in real time and in your face. The internet is the medium of this age, this cultural paradigm, the dispenser of information and interpretation. Only recently has the realization, transformation and diffusion of spatial data into meaningful digital thematic cartographic representation has truly begun to be realized. Big internet players like Google maps and Microsoft Earth just start to scratch the surface of providing a means for everyday users to understand their spatial surroundings. Almost every month or every week there appears to be a new geoapplication, geoplugin, geoenhancement or geotool aimed at giving the average user the power to leverage their spatial world in new and meaningful ways.
But, these are just new tools and toys, gadgets and gizmos. They have their place, they provide a form of spatial communication to the end user, displaying maps, directions or some other cross reference of geo-locational functionality. These tools and internet gizmos have given geography the gift of being hip and cool in some amazingly banal fashion, now geography can mingle with email and whatever social networking site of the day. Unlike no other time in the last 50 years geography is cool, all the cool kids are doing it! GeoTagging, flicker,3d representations of our world, areal photography and oh where is my house in google maps!
But, what exactly does all this mean? How does this digital geoawareness and new found ability and tools to map our world effect the everyday user, the non geographer, the non cartographer? How does GIS truly play a role and what will the public be able to do with a GIS and will they even understand it? At what cost does this digital geoworld come to us and will it suffer qualty at the expense of the digital medium. These are questions I plan to address in upcomming blog posts and I hope to create some form of dialog. There is currently quite a few blogs discussing these tools and additional resources, but I hope instead to open a forum a little as to how all this affects us. Please note, these are my opinions, sorta an oped piece.
I really like your arguments here and would probably go so far as to say I agree with them. I still see a massive divide between the new found cartographers (the bloggers, the flickr users, the google mashup people) and the actually GIS, Cartographic Science, Geo Analysis community. The current excitement generated by all of these new GI user experiences is good - google earth allows my mom and dad to ‘visit’ places they could never have imagined, i can show my photographs geo-tagged. But is this really a massive step forward for the general public? For the man on the street?
I am not so sure.
Hell I thought a few years back that searching Yahoo maps (for limited US Cities) and being able to do a “search businesses nearby” was the best thing since…. well sliced bread. However its a feature i have not used in years now. I seem to be able to find all the local businesses i need when i am in a strange city without consulting the maps. A phonebook actually works better and is more percise (if not as funky).
I think the folksonomy approaches are great (from a user perspective) but will allow the definitions of things to become a “bit too fuzzy”. With everyone able to tag and push a push pin on a map can we really keep accuracy.
Exciting times we are in; even more exciting to come!
Looking forward to keeping tabs on the postings.
I agree, all the new technology out there is just crazy. I feel we are definitely living in exciting times. I think one of the real questions the professional geography community will have to face is what value does the common user see in the spatial tools and data that are provided. As a geographer and technofiles I love all the new tools and gadgets, but the real question is how do they provide value to me as a user.
I think there are allot of hard questions ahead of the Geospatial community as the boundaries between specialty and generality continue to blur.